M4A file identification

[robinfriedli]

I was wondering how exiftool recognizes M4A files because I'm getting some inconsistent result where some of them get identified as MP4 files (so video/mp4 instead of audio/mp4 despite being audio files).

Code Select Expand

curl -s https://filebroker.io/api/get-object/c432752a-d6c4-47ea-96a4-8f86974d5b76.m4a | exiftool -j --struct -fast2 -api largefilesupport=1 - correctly identifies as M4A (FileType M4A and MIMEType audio/mp4).

Code Select Expand

curl -s https://filebroker.io/api/get-object/7b2bb160-417a-4cf2-88ac-b40c1fa2921d.m4a | exiftool -j --struct -fast2 -api largefilesupport=1 - However exiftool shows this one as FileType MP4 and MIMEType video/mp4

The main difference is that the first of them is an iTunes music file and the other one isn't. Both have a cover art video stream shown by ffprobe, though the first is mjepg and the second is png. I've checked mdls and both files are shown with kMDItemKind "Apple MPEG-4 audio"

[Phil Harvey]

ExifTool looks at the MajorBrand identification in the 'ftyp' box.  For these 2 files:

Code Select Expand

> exiftool *.m4a -p '$majorbrand# - $majorbrand'
M4A  - Apple iTunes AAC-LC (.M4A) Audio
mp42 - MP4 v2 [ISO 14496-14]
- Phil